Why Are Whales So Massive ~ Saturday’s Digs

G’day everyone,
 
Did you know that whales haven’t always been so huge? A study by Nicholas Pyenson, a paleobiologist with Smithsonian’s Museum of Natural History, determined that ancient whales were significantly smaller than today’s behemoths. Read more ... https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/researchers-figure-out-why-whales-got-so-gosh-darned-big-180963441/
 
What I enjoyed about this article is that, instead of picking an answer from a dartboard of possibilities, Pyenson’s team calculated the length of extinct whale species from the size of their fossilized skulls. Those old whales were still very large, but they didn’t get massive (over 33 feet long) until a relatively few years ago — 4.5 million really, but that’s only 10% of the time that whale species have existed altogether.
 
A likely scenario for their more-recent gigantism may be due to climactic change, another study points out. An oncoming ice age may have forced whales to migrate further between food sources. They’d have to get chubby in order to save enough energy to make long-distance journeys.
 
It’s another hypothesis to tack onto the dartboard of theories. 
 
I wonder how this conjecture applies to gigantism on land? It doesn’t seem likely that all the largest of ancient reptiles and dinosaurs became freakishly huge because their favorite plants just happened to be thousands of miles apart, does it? In the vast oceans, blending food sources was relatively an easy process, but patches of krill, for example, could be separated due to concentrations of foods into particular areas.
 
Sure, migratory patterns exist on land today as well, but the vast majority of migrating animals are tiny when compared to many of the beasts of the past.
 
The article further points out that the argument for gigantism occurred as a means of avoiding predators doesn’t appear to hold true for whales. Whales were becoming larger around the time their potential predators were becoming extinct. Something doesn't add up. It would seem that there isn’t one tidy answer for gigantism.

Have a nice day.
-R.J.

Comments